Our experts examine the hottest new research
CUTTING EDGE
Big stars come with an entourage
A closer look at seemingly lonely massive stellar objects reveals they’re rarely without companions
Among the glories of Sagittarius, the king of the southern summer sky, M17 deserves to be better known. Just about visible to a keenly sighted naked-eye observer, the Omega (also called the Swan or Lobster) Nebula may lack a distinct form, but it is substantial. Lying between 5,000 and 6,000 lightyears away, it contains more gas – fuel for star formation – than the Orion Nebula, making it one of the best laboratories we have for understanding how stars form.
We look to M17 to help us understand the formation of the most massive stars, those with more than eight times the mass of the Sun. A cluster of these, formed within the last few million years, sits at the heart of the nebula and this month’s paper takes a closer look at them than ever before. The team behind the paper used the marvellous GRAVITY instrument attached to the Very Large Telescope (VLT) to get extremely high-resolution images of the nebula’s core, with the aim of identifying any companions to the massive stars that live there.
The question of whether the largest stars have companions, and what they’re like if they do exist, is thought to be important in trying to understand the process by which such massive stars form. All star formation is a race, between the processes by which material is accreted onto the forming protostar and those that will power the nuclear fusion at the star’s core. Once the latter get going, powerful stellar winds will prevent further accretion and growth, cutting off star formation, so any massive star needs to form quickly.
“Massive companions are common in M17, meaning massive binaries must form early in the evolution of such a system”
Missing companions
Theories of massive star formation range from the merging of smaller protostars, to interactions in dense clusters of new stars, to extreme examples of the processes that drive the formation of normal stars. Each of these possibilities will have left its mark on the population of binary stars in M17. Previous studies used spectroscopic techniques to try and pin down the fraction of massive stars in this young cluster that have companions, and seemed to show that the cluster was unusually devoid of such systems. This made it an intriguing target for GRAVITY, which is capable of finding more distant and less-massive companions.
Sure enough, all six of the stars targeted in the cluster turn out to have at least one companion, sharing 14 between them, with masses ranging from three to 50 times that of the Sun. That’s enough to conclude that, as in other clusters that have been studied, massive companions are common in M17, meaning massive binaries must form early in the evolution of such a system.
We can also say more about the binaries: there is a wide variety of separations, from stars not much further apart than Earth and the Sun, to those that are 120 times that distance apart, and a distinct lack of systems in which the two stars are of equal mass. Unfortunately, no one theory of massive star formation explains all of these features, so all we can really say is that more observations are needed. Luckily, with GRAVITY and the Very Large Telescope, astronomers have the tools to do the job.
Prof Chris Lintott is an astrophysicist and co-presenter on The Sky at Night.
He was reading… On the origin of close massive binaries in the M17 star-forming region by E Bordier et al.
Read it online at: arxiv.org/abs/2203.05036