By Freya Parr

Published: Thursday, 26 May 2022 at 12:00 am


Butterfly Conservation has revealed that there has been a 26% increase in the number of butterfly species threatened with extinction.

A new Red List has been published in Insect Conservation and Diversity, with 62 UK species of butterfly assessed. Of those, four are classed as being extinct in Britain, with 24 threatened (including eight that are endangered) and five considered to be near threatened.

The four species that are considered to be extinct in the UK are the black-veined white, large tortoiseshell (pictured below), large copper and mazarine blue butterflies.

""
Large tortoiseshell butterfly. © Neil Hulme

The data was gathered by volunteers through the UK Butterfly Monitoring Scheme and Butterflies for the New Millennium recording schemes, and assessed by scientists from Butterfly Conservation.

The risk of extinction for these butterfly species is increasing, with the numbers of threatened butterfly species having increased since the last time data was published in 2010, based on assessments up to the year 2004.

The impact of climate change is said to be notable from these findings, with all four butterfly species (large heath, Scotch argus, northern brown argus and mountain ringlet) that are distributed in the north of the UK – and therefore having adapted to cooler or damper climates – having now been listed as threatened or near threatened.

“Shockingly, half of Britain’s remaining butterfly species are listed as threatened or near threatened on the new Red List,” says Dr Richard Fox, head of science for Butterfly Conservation.

“Even prior to this new assessment, British butterflies were among the most threatened in Europe, and now the number of threatened species in Britain has increased by five, an increase of more than one-quarter. While some species have become less threatened, and a few have even dropped off the Red List, the overall increase clearly demonstrates that the deterioration of the status of British butterflies continues apace.”

""
Large blue butterfly. © Keith Warmington

Some species’ statuses have improved. For example, the large blue (pictured above) has moved from critically endangered to near threatened, following a highly successful reintroduction programme and ongoing conservation work. The high brown fritillary (pictured below) is also no longer critically endangered and is considered endangered instead, thanks to intense conservation work. The pearl-bordered fritillary and Duke of Burgundy have moved from endangered to vulnerable.

""
High brown fritillary butterfly. © Iain H Leach

“Where we are able to target conservation work, we have managed to bring species back from the brink, but with the extinction risk increasing for more species than are decreasing, more must be done to protect our butterflies from the effects of changing land management and climate change,” adds Dr Fox.

“Without action it is likely that species will be lost from Britain’s landscapes for good, but Butterfly Conservation is taking bold steps to improve key landscapes for butterflies and reduce the extinction risk of many threatened species.”

The full Red List compared to the species’ previous categories:

Species New GB Red List Category Previous GB Red List
Black-veined White Regionally Extinct Regionally Extinct
Large Copper Regionally Extinct Regionally Extinct
Large Tortoiseshell Regionally Extinct Regionally Extinct
Mazarine Blue Regionally Extinct Regionally Extinct
Black Hairstreak Endangered Endangered
Glanville Fritillary Endangered Endangered
Grayling Endangered Vulnerable
Heath Fritillary Endangered Endangered
High Brown Fritillary Endangered Critically Endangered
Large Heath Endangered Vulnerable
Wall Endangered Near Threatened
Wood White Endangered Endangered
Adonis Blue Vulnerable Near Threatened
Brown Hairstreak Vulnerable Vulnerable
Chalk Hill Blue Vulnerable Near Threatened
Duke of Burgundy Vulnerable Endangered
Grizzled Skipper Vulnerable Vulnerable
Marsh Fritillary Vulnerable Vulnerable
Northern Brown Argus Vulnerable Vulnerable
Pearl-bordered Fritillary Vulnerable Endangered
Scotch Argus Vulnerable Least Concern
Silver-spotted Skipper Vulnerable Near Threatened
Silver-studded Blue Vulnerable Vulnerable
Small Heath Vulnerable Near Threatened
Small Pearl-bordered Fritillary Vulnerable Near Threatened
Swallowtail Vulnerable Near Threatened
White Admiral Vulnerable Vulnerable
White-letter Hairstreak Vulnerable Endangered
Dark Green Fritillary Near Threatened Least Concern
Large Blue Near Threatened Critically Endangered
Lulworth Skipper Near Threatened Near Threatened
Mountain Ringlet Near Threatened Near Threatened
Small Blue Near Threatened Near Threatened

Comparison with previous Red List: 

Red List threat category Number of species qualifying in new Red List Number of species qualifying in 2011 Red List
Regionally Extinct 4 4
Critically Endangered 0 2
Endangered 8 8
Vulnerable 16 9
Near Threatened 5 11
Least Concern 29 28
Total 62 62

Main image: Small blue butterfly. © Iain H Leach