While these bikes have a gravity focus, they’re designed to let you climb to the top under your own steam in a relatively painless fashion – and with enough energy left to rip down the timed stages at full gas.

While there’s a 35mm reach difference between the two frames, the G1’s effective top tube length is just 23mm longer, because of its steeper seat tube angle (78.5 degrees compared with 77 degrees).

Add in the 5mm-shorter stem on the GeoMetron and the fact that I slammed its saddle forwards on its rails, and I could get the seat-to-grips distances of the two bikes to within a few millimetres of each other.

The seated position on both bikes is comfortable, thanks to their steep effective seat angles, which puts you in a good place over the bottom bracket to deliver an efficient pedal stroke.

Both bikes can winch up steep climbs without spinning out or wandering all over the trail, but the G1 has more laboured steering and takes more concentration to control at slow speeds up steep gradients.

Still, its longer chainstays and more forward-seated climbing position let you keep enough weight over the front, even though the wheel is slung further forward.

In terms of pedal bob, on both bikes I was happy to spend most of my climbing time with the shock in its open setting, only firming up the rear suspension on the steepest ascents.

This is thanks to decent levels of anti-squat – GeoMetron tells me the G1 has around 110 per cent anti-squat at sag, while, reading the chart for the Rallon, that figure is a little higher, at around 125 per cent.

The Orbea certainly feels like the sprightlier climber, though. It’s just over 2kg lighter and its Maxxis tyres have a midweight EXO+ casing and reasonably easy-rolling 3C MaxxTerra compound – perhaps a little trail-orientated for an enduro bike.

The GeoMetron has similar rear rubber, with Schwalbe’s Super Trail casing and ADDIX Soft compound, but a beefier, tackier Super Gravity ADDIX UltraSoft front tyre, which undoubtedly adds drag.

That said, both these bikes will get you to the top of most climbs comfortably and neither is a lousy climber for their suspension travel and category.

Traditional vs extreme mountain bike geometry – descending performance

Getting gravity on your side makes these speed machines a ton of fun to ride. With their wish-list build kits, I didn’t have issues with the performance of any of their components.

But this test isn’t to determine which has the best spec – it’s about frame design.

I’m very familiar with the Fox suspension on the Orbea, so it didn’t take long to feel at home using my regular settings. The Rallon has a progressive leverage curve, so I ran almost 35 per cent sag and removed all volume spacers from the shock.

I am less familiar with the EXT ERA fork and Storia V3 shock. Still, when I collected the bike from GeoMetron, the brand’s people helped me set it up, swapped springs and gave me all the info I needed.

I began testing on more mellow, flowy trails and instantly felt comfortable on the Rallon. Your body weight is nicely balanced between the wheels, it feels like many other bikes we’ve ridden and its handling is intuitive.

The bottom bracket is a couple of percentage points more neutrally located between the wheels than on the G1, which is a little more rear-biased because of its stretched front centre, even with its longer back end.

There’s a nippy and urgent feel to the Orbea’s handling on smooth-flow trails. This allows it to be very reactive, without it in any way feeling nervous, so you can play around, pumping into small berms and quickly popping the bike from side to side. It’s not a trail bike, but it has some agility.

Andy Lloyd / Our Media

The longer wheelbase of the GeoMetron means it isn’t as entertaining to ride on these smoother tracks.

Rather, it provides excellent stability and calms the trail down. This may be ideal for those wanting maximum security, but riders looking for an engaging ride may feel underwhelmed.

That’s not to say the G1 can’t be playful, but it takes more effort to get it to feel alive on this type of trail.

Getting rowdier

Taking these bikes to terrain that properly challenged them highlighted a few more differences. Off-piste trails with a moderate gradient illustrated how the GeoMetron benefits from being ridden with more gusto.

With its front wheel 63mm further forward (from the bottom bracket) than the Orbea’s and a more rearward weight balance, I had to make a conscious effort to ride with my weight over the front of the bike. I also quickly learned that my usual range of movement wouldn’t cut it on the G1.

On my first runs, I found myself hampered by understeer in turns, unable to maintain my line. Adopting an aggressive, forward posture on the bike helped me get to grips with it.

To ride the GeoMetron with the commitment needed takes a fair amount of courage, because you have to shift forwards more than expected. It also gives you a good workout, as you have to support more of your weight with your arms.

However, when you get things right on the G1 it hooks up in the corners and provides a predictable platform to push from and let loose. Long flat turns are a definite highlight – here, the bike’s stability is rewarded with masses of grip and composure.

Throwing the Rallon into the off-piste, it demonstrates an eagerness to let you do what you want with it. I could ride it on autopilot and trust that it’d get the job done, and it didn’t take any additional thought or planning to ride at the edge of my comfort zone.

Andy Lloyd / Our Media

That gave me extra bandwidth for concentrating on other aspects of riding, such as braking and line choice.

I found I could use less body movement to manoeuvre the bike around turns, and was able to use my legs to support my weight and my arms to control the bike, making it less physical to ride.

The Orbea has a sharp accuracy that lets you adjust and make corrections on the fly without significant pauses in momentum.

On the G1, mid-turn line changes or fast adjustments to where you want to place your tyres on the trail are hindered by the bike’s slower reactions. I also noticed that the GeoMetron punishes mistakes more severely.

The Rallon could be wrestled to correct riding errors, whereas the G1 was less forgiving and I more often found myself stalling on the exit of turns.

Andy Lloyd / Our Media

There are though undoubtedly situations where the GeoMetron’s front wheel being further in front is a noticeable benefit. It shines when dropping down steep chutes onto flat fireroads or heading into 90-degree catch berms with a flat exit.

Tackling these features on the G1 gives you more confidence to hit them hard, because you don’t feel like the front wheel is going to tuck under. Still, to make it behave through these sections, you need to keep that commitment to the front of the bike.

It’s easy to end up a little too far back, which quickly removes weight from the front wheel, leaving you pushing the front end through corners, rather than just gripping and turning.

On the Rallon, I never encountered any trails that were steep enough to make the 64-degree head angle feel insufficient, although if you often ride super-steep drops into catch berms you may wish it were a little slacker.

It didn’t take such an ‘attacking’ position to keep the front wheel where I wanted it and not have to worry about it blowing out of turns.

Horses for courses

So, which of these two would I pick? Well, for the trails I tested, in the conditions I had, it’d be the Orbea.

Is that to say it’s the best bike? It’s not that simple.

First, it has more familiar geometry and, even though I rode these bikes back-to-back for several weeks, maybe I just didn’t have enough time to get used to the G1. Also, most of my testing was on slippery, technical off-piste trails.

Andy Lloyd / Our Media

I put in some uplift days at BikePark Wales, too, but it still couldn’t offer speeds found on a dry high-speed mainline track such as Pleney in Morzine – a track I think would really suit the GeoMetron, which I feel has a higher ceiling for outright speed.

The G1 has plenty to offer, but it requires more rider muscle and suitable trails to realise its potential. I could more consistently ride the Rallon fast, even if I was closer to its upper limits. Of course, testing on different trails in drier conditions could have led me to a different conclusion.

One big bonus of the G1 is its sizing – and GeoMetron’s incredible customer service. For tall riders whose range of movement is bigger, it makes total sense, its longer frame allowing them to more easily transfer weight.

So, is there a geometry sweet spot? As the Rallon shows, contemporary geometry will do everything well. The G1, on the other hand, does some things to an exemplary level, but is compromised in other areas.

You need to weigh up what type of riding you do, how you want your bike to behave and how aggressive a rider you are. I reckon the GeoMetron will remain an outlier over the coming years, with its slacker-than-downhill-bike head angle and its medium size being longer than the extra-large Orbea.

The good news is that, with dropper posts getting longer (such as the 240mm OneUp) and seat tubes being made correspondingly shorter, many bike companies are giving riders the opportunity to pick between two, or even three, sizes to best suit their needs, so you’re not limited to the ‘new normal’ geometry of the Rallon or the extremes of the G1 but can find your own sweet spot.

Verdict

GeoMetron G1 with EXT ERA fork

Andy Lloyd / Our Media

It takes an active riding style and the right trails to reach the G1’s full potential.

Mismanage your weight distribution and it can cause simple mistakes that are hard to correct, but get it right, and this bike offers tons of stability and grip, and has the potential for crazy speeds.

Orbea Rallon M-LTD

Andy Lloyd / Our Media

If you’re looking for an enduro bike with intuitive handling, then the Rallon is a strong choice. I found it easy to take it to my limits, requiring no changes in riding style or technique.

It keeps you engaged on all types of trails, but doesn’t make you feel nervous on any.

---