How James Hitchmough used his Sheffield garden to trial South African summer perennials

From our archives: Professor James Hitchmough’s Sheffield garden is a test bed for his scholarly work and a masterclass in planting combinations. Words Caroline Beck, photographs Richard Bloom

By Juliet Giles

Published: Monday, 20 February 2023 at 12:00 am

Professor James Hitchmough is a hard man to get hold of. Apologetic emails from South Africa, China, the Orkney Islands or Kyrgyzstan explained he was photographing plants in high-altitude meadows. When I finally meet him, Stan his dog upstages him, scattering pots of exotic cuttings before barging into the borders after a cat. None of this fazes the professor. “My tolerance for disorder,” he explains, “is very high.”

Disorder is a word he uses often. As Professor of Horticultural Ecology in the Department of Landscape Architecture at Sheffield University, he’s spent 20 years probing how much ‘naturalism’ (for this read ‘chaos’) people can tolerate. Scrutinising his environment is second-nature to him. He grew up in a pit village in Northumberland surrounded by spoil heaps. “I asked myself, why is this place so bloody awful and what would make it better?” It’s a question he’s spent a lifetime answering.

IN BRIEF

What Richly planted small garden.

Where Sheffield, South Yorkshire.

Size Approximately 400 square metres.

Soil Loam, but with 100ml of fine gravel on the top soil as an establishment mulch as many of the plants need good sharp drainage.

Climate Temperate, with average temperatures varying between -3ºC in winter to 25ºC in the summer.

Hardiness rating USDA 8.

His own back garden behind his terraced house on one of Sheffield’s vertiginous hills is his outdoor laboratory. It was derelict when he bought it, meaning waist-high weeds needed to be cleared and remaining trees pruned to open up the shade canopy, and leave the remaining two-thirds open. The stylised meadow he has created unfolds from late winter onwards when bulbs and a low understory of woodland plants, such as primulas and ranunculus, reduces the area of bare soil that weeds would otherwise swiftly colonise, with taller summer plants emerging as the spring layer dies back. “Here I can examine how plants perform and use volumes of space as they grow, and from a design point of view it’s vital to be able to conceptualise this,” he says.

© Richard Bloom

The plants in James Hitchmough’s small city garden are like stamps in his passport, numerous and exotic. For the past decade, however, South African species, such as the Kniphofia ‘Jane Henry’ and Gladiolus ‘Ruby’ seen above, have been his abiding interest. Most South African species familiar to gardeners, come from eastern summer rainfall areas, but James has been researching plants from western winter rainfall areas, such as the Hex River and the Komsberg, which are far less common. “It gets down to minus eight, so many of these species, such as Bulbinella latifolia and Watsonia marlothii, grow really well in the UK,” he says.

© Richard Bloom

Summer plants, such as Echinacea pallida and Kniphofia albomontana, are selected mostly to have leafless stems so the borders have a certain wildness rather than a neat en bloc structure. Here they combine with Eryngium bourgatii ‘Picos Blue’, Echinops ritro, Echinacea purpurea ‘Prairie Splendor’, Agapanthus campanulatus subsp. patens, Kniphofia ‘Jane Henry’, Crocosmia masoniorum and Hemerocallis ‘Lemon Bells’, combine to bring a ‘supercharged nature’ aspect to his richly planted borders. “Initially there wasn’t a warm reception to the idea of naturalistic vegetation,” says James, “but now it’s become much more normalised, and things like the Olympic Park [where James and his Sheffield University colleague Professor Nigel Dunnett acted as planting design consultants] played a major part in that. It’s having your cake and eating it, but what’s wrong with that?”

© Richard Bloom

Five lessons for a city space

Don’t discount exotic species. Many South African plants are very happy in urban Sheffield.
A good ground layer of plants, out of which other, taller things can emerge, will keep the garden looking good in the early months, so plant large numbers of shade-tolerant understorey plants, such as primulas and ranunculus.
Trying to have flowers from January to November means that you have to open the vegetation up more than if you just want a garden from April to September. It’s more work, but you’re rewarded with greater visual interest.
Dogs and gardens can be tricky. This is the first garden James has had with a dog – one that occasionally wants to dig a big hole.
Don’t be in a big rush to discard plants that don’t seem to be performing. Give them another year as it makes a big difference.

© Richard Bloom

During his time as Professor of Horticultural Ecology at theUniversity of Sheffield, James Hitchmough used his Sheffield garden to trial new plants.

James’s favourite summer plants

Hemerocallis ‘Lemon Bells’

© Richard Bloom

Multi-headed, lemon-coloured, lily-like flowers with bronzed backs blooming in midsummer, which hold up well above foliage. 1.2m. RHS H6, USDA 4a-9b†.