It seems critics and audiences are a little divided on the streamer’s adaptation of the beloved animation.

By Lidia Molina-Whyte

Published: Thursday, 22 February 2024 at 13:33 PM

---

Netflix’s Avatar: The Last Airbender has just landed on the streamer, giving the Gaang the live-action treatment.

But how does it hold up against the beloved Nickleodeon animation it’s been adapted from? Well, the jury is rather divided.

At the time of writing, the series holds a 67 per cent rating from critics on review aggregator site Rotten Tomatoes, with critics largely praising the Netflix adaptation’s cast, but commenting on a lack of heart.

In its review, RadioTimes.com wrote: “While it’s bold that the showrunners have attempted a differing tone and direction for this latest outing, it feels like part of the essence and artistry has been lost in the process.

“Comparisons aside, the series proves a decent fantasy entry, setting up a compelling showdown between Aang and his allies against the fearsome Fire Nation.”

Elsewhere, The Guardian called it a “thrilling ride”, but Variety said “cheesy acting and some Disney Channel-like dialogue turn what could have been a resounding epic adventure into a whimpering thud”.

The audience score is higher, however, with a 75 per cent rating, though it’s worth noting that there are currently just over 50 reviews from viewers on Rotten Tomatoes. It’s early days still, with fans yet to work their way through the series.

Still, the reception on social media has been rather positive, with many noting how the adaptation has exceeded their expectations despite original creators Michael Dante DiMartino and Bryan Konietzko not being involved. (The pair left the show during production due to creative differences.)

One fan wrote that the show was “squashing every negative thought” they had about it prior to it airing. “Every character is so good, the bending looks amazing, the settings and scenes look beautiful, just finished episode 2, and already want the 2nd and 3rd season!” they added.

#AvatarTheLastAirbender is literally squashing every negative thought i had about it prior to the release! Every character is so good, the bending looks amazing, the settings and scenes look beautiful, just finished episode 2, and already want the 2nd and 3rd season! pic.twitter.com/chZZrcG6LH

— ⁴pinkmulti 💗 (@blackpink4lif91) February 22, 2024