Did you know how it was going to play out when you first signed on to play Eddie?

Well, I wasn’t optioned. An option is when you’re kind of asked to come back for numerous seasons. So I knew that I was only in one season.

But I thought there might be potential to come back if the character worked in that world. Joe Keery, I remember talking to him about it, he wasn’t optioned in the first season, but they started writing more for him.

I’d be lying if I said I didn’t have half an eye on maybe trying to crowbar my way back in! But no, I think they had a pretty clear idea of what they wanted to do for the end of the season. And the fact that I was able to be part of it is a real privilege.

When did they tell you how Eddie was going to die?

It was during the pandemic, they texted me and they said, like, ‘Can you play the guitar?’ I said, ‘Yes’. And then that was about two months into the pandemic, and then a month later, they sent me the last script. And I was like ‘Are you serious?’ They were like, ‘Yeah.’ And I was like ‘Okay.’

So I went and bought a guitar and then practised manically for months until we ended up shooting the thing.

I was gonna ask if you really learned that guitar solo – is it all you?

It’s mostly me. Yeah. I was kind of trying to be realistic with what I could do. I’ve been playing since I was a kid but I’m no virtuoso.

So I had most of the song down but for the solo we had to fly someone, a black belt metal guitarist to help with that. The rest of it? I had a stab at it, yeah.

We’ve had beloved characters die in Stranger Things before, but it feels like Eddie has a particularly epic exit. Like he says, it’s the most metal concert ever. Was it nice to get that huge send-off for the character?

Absolutely it was. It was so thrilling to do on the day– me and Gaten [Matarazzo, who plays Dustin] were on top of the caravan in the middle of the Upside Down playing Metallica. It was great fun.

And also, I think the timing of it was brilliant. For the whole crew, it felt like the first time that people had been in a kind of live music situation since the pandemic, so it was a joyous celebration on the day. It’s a fantastic conclusion to the character and yeah, I feel very very lucky.

If they did ask you return in some way would you come back?

Come onnnn. Obviously, yeah!

Maybe ghost Eddie could come back with ghost Barb.

Maybe! Yeah, I don’t know, I was thinking… me and Joe Keery were discussing ways in which I could [come back]. Maybe I’d be a figment of Gaten’s imagination or something like that, if there could be some room for something a bit supernatural.

But my suspicion is that Eddie has done what he needed to do for the Brothers.

Speaking of Gaten, there’s some very moving scenes between you two in these last episodes. What were those like to film?

Well, I’ve waxed lyrically about that boy in various interviews, and I never get bored of it really. He is an extraordinarily talented young man. I think he has grown so much during the filming of all of these seasons, and especially this season. His playfulness, his timing… and in this season, we get to see his depth, the depth of his humanity.

He’s just extraordinary. And being near that, especially in someone so young is a really thrilling thing. I had so much fun getting into that stuff with him. I’m so excited to see what he’s going to do with his career.

There was also a lot of love for Eddie and Steve’s bromance. Some even wanted it to be a romance. I don’t know if you saw any of that online. Did you?

Yeah, well, all I can say is… how did they know?

It’s all subtext.

Yeah, yeah. Well, you know, just… people can dream, I guess. I dunno! I don’t really know what to say to that.

I guess in another world, maybe that would have played out in Stranger Things 5.

Maybe! Maybe, maybe, maybe? Yeah.

Netflix

Eddie has that big exit, and then there’s this coda where Dustin tells his uncle what really happened, despite the town still hating him. Would you like to see Eddie’s name cleared in season five?

I think that would be satisfying for the audience. I think Eddie made the ultimate sacrifice for a town that thought he was a monster, which is a level of heroism that’s kind of hard to comprehend.

So I think it would be nice for him to have his name cleared. But as I said, I’m not allowed in the writers’ room, so we’ll see what the grown-ups think.

You’ve joined the ranks of these untimely fan-favourite deaths in Stranger Things – Barb in season one, Bob in season two, Alexei last time. Now, Eddie! Are you happy to continue that tradition of breaking fans hearts?

I don’t know about breaking fans’ hearts! I feel incredibly honoured to be a part of a show that has a fanbase as devoted as this one.

It comes around once in a career really, or kind of once in a generation, but it’s something that touches so many people’s hearts of all different generations. It’s a very rare thing to be a part of it. I just feel extremely lucky.

And to any fans mourning, do you have any words of comfort?

Hey, well – thank you, for having Eddie while he was here.

Read more:

• Will Max die in Stranger Things?
• Stranger Things 4 part 2 ending explained
• Stranger Things 4 soundtrack: every song featured in the Netflix show
• Who dies in Stranger Things 4 part 2?
• Stranger Things 4 drops hints about Will’s sexuality in emotional scenes
• Stranger Things 4 part 2 review: A barnstorming end to an epic season

Stranger Things 4 part 2 is now streaming on Netflix. Check out our guides to the best series on Netflix and the best movies on Netflix. If you’re looking for more to watch, check out our TV Guide.

• Sign up for Netflix from £6.99 a month. Netflix is also available on Sky Glass and Virgin Media Stream.

The latest issue of Radio Times magazine is on sale now – subscribe now and get the next 12 issues for only £1. For more from the biggest stars in TV, listen to the Radio Times podcast with Jane Garvey.

---